Why Israelis are in such a bind?

Unfortunately Israeli homeowners have it rough.  You would think that wouldn’t be the case. After all, if you review the figures from the previous article, real estate prices in Israel are up some 300% in the last decade. But at the same time, not everyone timed the market just right. Some also turned of age only recently, and are now paying mortgage rates through the roof. Why is that – and what does it mean for you?

Firstly, let’s talk about two parallel trends: trends that are especially fascinating in terms of their divergence, perhaps from much of the rest of the Western world. For one, take America for example. Yes, in the Old Country, good old USA, though higher interest rates often mean that banks will rake in more on the loans on their balance sheet, it also means that there’s the possibility of a credit crisis. In 2008, bank loans were packaged into mortgage-backed securities which collapsed almost overnight. In Israel, that’s not the case. Mortgages are not resold as bonds which go up and down with supply and demand.  This means that banks need to – and do – make a killing so as to avoid risk in the face of rising rates and otherwise crippling inflation.

“Israel is unique”, noted Professor Yamir Aron, Israel’s Chief Banker and World-famous economist. In the 1980’s, Israel’s banks took a massive hit when hyperinflation knocked the wind out of the entire banking system. Then, mortgages were not linked to the inflation rate or the Bank of Israel rate.  As a result, homeowners were living in seventh heaven as the real payment they made on their mortgages was zilch, and banks scrambled to survive. What happened in response? That’s where things get interesting: banks went to the opposite extreme, hedging against risk by linking every loan to the Prime rate, or inflation, or some combination of the two.  In effect, today 90% of Israeli debt now fluctuates with the interest rate and the CPI. In other words, Israelis are getting killed, siphoning funds off just to make ends meet, literally pinching pennies not to default and pay extra financing charges. Yes, it’s been tough.

Secondly, in addition to the decision of the Bank of Israel when Prime was low, to allow Israelis to take a larger ratio of their mortgage in Prime, another entrenched reality is now very much at play. The Bank of Israel limits mortgages to 40% of one’s monthly income, a very draconian, yet safe approach.  This means that Israeli homeowners aren’t overly leveraged. On the other hand, it’s boomeranged because instead of Israeli homeowners taking a larger chunk of their mortgage under locked-in terms (not linking their premiums to the CPI, or the Prime rate), they have done the very opposite.  They’ve stocked up on variable rates which can send them into financial tailspin.  Why is that? Because the variable rates require significantly lower initial payments when the mortgage first kicks off.  This is the only way to afford a home or buy up to a larger property, which come back to bite, haemorrhaging liquidity that would otherwise be disposable income that could better serve families’ needs and fuel economic growth. In its stead, banks have been pocketing huge interest premiums at the expense of the homeowner.  Currently, Israeli Finance Minister, Bezalel Smotrich, is rumoured to be making moves to increase banks’ overall tax burden.  Additionally, he is trying to make it a requirement that banks pay customers minimal interest on their checking account balance.

Things in Israel are dicey, only playing into home prices going higher, yet at the same time,there is political uncertainty and nobody knows how the mortgage fallout will play out. Chances are that banks won’t be forking out cash for free, and any move to force banks’ hand could backfire as well. For now, Israeli homeowners are in a bind.   Banks are paying out hefty dividends and home prices keep on rising. This is because banks which are financing both the contractors’ building costs and buyers’ home purchases have no interest whatsoever to see prices inch even a millimetre lower.

Related Posts

You May Also Read

tel aviv housing
GOLD MORTGAGES

When will they go down?

Betting on Israel is pretty much like using Grays Sports Almanac in “Back to the Future” to bet on playoff showdowns, or the All-Star Game.

Read More »